[1+1=2]

OneAndOneIs2

« The RibbonHypocrisy, noun »

Fri, Jan 15, 2010

[Icon][Icon]The sweetest words

• Post categories: Omni, In The News, Technology

...are "I told you so"

I started saying, years ago, when the next-gen console wars between Xbox 360 and PS3 were just starting to heat up, that neither of them would win because the Wii was clearly superior to either of them.

Not just because it was cheaper for customers and more profitable for Nintendo (PS3 and the 360 both cost more than they sold for when they launched, unlike the Wii), but because Nintendo had clearly understood that gaming superiority isn't about how close to photo-realistic the graphics are.

All the Xbox and PS had to offer was souped-up versions of the same games the originals had, and irrelevant excess features. Sure, you can watch a DVD on your Xbox, but so what? Everyone already has DVD players, we buy games machines to play games on, not watch movies.

The Wii had a completely new way of interacting with the games, and because you couldn't hide crap games behind beautiful graphics, they had no choice but to make the games fun to play.

The detractors of the Wii generally point to its relatively-underpowered graphics hardware as a huge flaw. They're quite right that I've never seen a Wii game as close to photo-realistic as the 360 or PS3 can manage.

But so what? Gaming is about having fun, and games don't become less fun because they have less-sophisticated graphics hardware.

You might just as well say that The Simpsons will never be as entertaining as Big Brother, because the primitive, blocky cartoons don't look realistic enough.

So it's nice to see on ars technica that the Wii is still unarguably superior to both the Xbox and the Playstation in one arena that is both measurable and highly-important: Sales numbers.

It must be particularly galling for Microsoft, the company that dismissed the Wii as underpowered and lacking in features, to be watching their own machine come last, with 1.3 million sold in December, when Nintendo came first with an amazing 3.8 million Wiis sold in the same period.

I was having an argument with a fervent gamer last year about consoles. He maintained that the graphics of the Xbox made it far superior to all other consoles. I held to my view that the Wii was the only console worth buying.

Neither of us changed the others' mind.. but judging by how the general population is voting with their wallets, I think I win this one on points :o)

5 comments

sinn3r
Comment from: sinn3r [Member] Email · http://sinn3r.org/
So it is.

Gothic I > Gothic III.

:)
15/01/10 @ 18:48
Yoshanuikabundi
Comment from: Yoshanuikabundi [Visitor]
You make a good point - from the point of view of the creators/marketers of the consoles, the Wii is inarguably superior. The only problem is that the Wii is a casual gaming console. "Hardcore" gamers - those that are into FPS and the like - really prefer more grunt with a familiar control mechanism. And don't make the mistake of thinking that graphics are the only reason you need grunt - there are loads of things, gameplay-wise, that are improved by better performing machines. AI is the classic example. The importance of graphics is blown out of proportion, by gamers and developers alike though, so it is the most obvious benefit.

Of course, why anyone would get a PS3 or Xbox 360 over a decent graphics card for their PC is totally beyond me... :)
16/01/10 @ 03:52
oneandoneis2
Comment from: oneandoneis2 [Member] · http://geekblog.oneandoneis2.org/
> The only problem is that the Wii is a casual gaming console

That's how MS & Sony think. The problem with that view is, hardcore gamers aren't actually a very big market. Casual gamers are.

Look at it this way: Would you rather get a penny every time somebody played Halo 3, or a penny every time somebody played Solitaire?

A penny for Quake 4, or for Minesweeper?

Hardcore gamers are wonderful customers - they'll spend more on hardware and more on software than a casual gamer. But they're a very small portion of the overall game market.

So yeah, for hardcore gamers, the Wii isn't a contender. But that's actually a good thing. It means the machine is cheap, the games are cheap, and the gameplay is simple and fun.

P.S. I don't really see why an FPS requires and particular amount of grunt - I've got a handheld that can do a perfectly good FPS..
16/01/10 @ 15:49
Steve Barker
Comment from: Steve Barker [Visitor] · http://www.stevesstats.blogspot.com
There are arguments for all tree major games machine players, and for the PC too. However, it is Nintendo who are widening the games market with innovation, something others do not seem to currently have.
16/01/10 @ 22:07
Matt
Comment from: Matt [Visitor] · http://matt-thornton.net/blog/
Point seems to be proven given that MS and Sony are both releasing their version of the Wii controller in the coming months. Will be interesting to see how that affects things considering it really is that "stand in front of your telly and pretend you're bowling" input mechanism that was the killer pitch - if the PS3 can do it too, then it'll be hard (other than cost) to say the Wii is still better.

Must admit, however, I have a PS3 and use it ONLY for Blu-Ray and streaming video wirelessly to my TV from a DLNA server elsewhere in my house. The gf has a Wii and we play Mario Kart a bit.
04/02/10 @ 15:18

Leave a comment


Your email address will not be revealed on this site.

Your URL will be displayed.
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Name, email & website)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will not be revealed.)
This is a captcha-picture. It is used to prevent mass-access by robots.
Please enter the characters from the image above. (case insensitive)
 

[Links][icon] My links

[Icon][Icon] Hmm.. new look for twitter? I hope it gets less "Ick! Change! Put it back!" nonsense than Facebook..
08/02/12

[Icon][Icon] Facebook Syndication Error
11/02/12

[Icon][Icon] I last listened to:
Johann Pachelbel - Canon in D major

[Icon][Icon] Most recent photo:
Submersible houseboat

[Icon][Icon]About Me

[Icon][Icon]About this blog

[Icon][Icon]My LQ profile

[Icon][Icon]My /. profile

[Icon][Icon]My Wishlist

[Icon]MyCommerce

[FSF Associate Member]


February 2012
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
 << <   > >>
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29        

Search

User tools

XML Feeds

eXTReMe Tracker

Valid XHTML 1.0 Transitional

Valid CSS!

[Valid RSS feed]

free open source blog